Guestbook

Here you can see what past guests have said about Montalto.

If you would like to add your comments please e-mail them to: or and we will put them in this page. Please specify if you want your name and email to be published or not.

Note: we used to have an open guestbook but have had to close it because hackers used it as a breech to enter our site. When will this problem be solved ?
For the moment, if you are interested in live comments you may visit our pages on TripAdvisor or on Facebook

christine_m_hayes (Newton, Massachusetts)

"Heaven on earth in the hills of Tuscany"
My husband and I and three ten year olds had a marvelous stay at the Castello di Montalto for a week in July 2009. We rented a three bedroom (the gamekeeper's cabin) with a large living room, spacious kitchen and two outdoor spaces, a table and chairs in the back and a large deck with table and chairs off the master with views over the Tuscan countryside. We enjoyed breakfast daily in the common room and ate outside under the grape arbor. The built in pool, ping pong table and grounds were enjoyed by all. The charming hosts had us over for wine and conversation and also hosted an impromtu barbecue one evening. The entire week was fantastic, and it was an ideal location (just outside of Siena) for various day trips to explore Tuscany. It was one of the highlights of the Italy trip. We look forward to our next trip back.

21 June 2010 - review from tripadvisor.com

SandSPS (Palm Springs)

"Tuscan dream!"
Stayed at Montalto for a week in Sept. 2008 and 2009 and had 2 wonderful experiences.
Steve had also visited the castle 16 years prior. This year we were joined by his sister and her husband, and we shared an apartment. The views from the windows are breathtaking, and Diana and Giovanni are gracious hosts. The fresh veggies from the garden are a real treat, too. Making bruschetta every night with the fresh bakery bread, eggplant, and beautiful tomatoes will be a tradition for our future trips to this Tuscan paradise. Montalto has a rustic charm that is hard to describe, but once you visit you become enthralled. At least we did.
We love the fact that the castle is our base, and we can return and relax after a long day visiting the surrounding Tuscan towns. We stopped in Orvieto on our way from Rome and had lunch at La Palomba, and then continued onto Castelnuovo Berardenga. Dinner was at Il Bivacco which is not to far from the castle. It has become very popular, but the pizza is wonderful. Our visits to Assisi, Montepulciano, Pisa, Montechiello, and Perugia were some of the highlights of our trip, but we visited at least 22 towns in 7 days. Our itinerary was overly ambitious, but well worth it. Driving back to Montalto on the last day we stopped to see Monteriggioni which is a small walled town with 8 towers. The sun had just come out after a light rain, and it was beautiful with double rainbows and spectacular vistas. It was hard to leave after such a great week, but we will return next year for sure!
We had many a great meal in Tuscany, but here were some of our favorites this time around. Cortona - Osteria del Teatro (amazing) Montechiello - Osteria La Porta (wonderful food and view) Pisa - Osteria dei Cavalieri (incredible, but reservations necessary) San Gimignano - La Mandragola (tuscan bean soup and walnut ravioli!) Siena - Osteria da Divo (elegant etruscan tombs), and Montefioralle - La Taverna del Guerrino (good food and incredible views). Truly a foodies dream.
Our favorite times were spent at the castle drinking wine and making our antipasto platters. For breakfast we would use the fresh castle eggs we had ordered to make a strata, or scrambled eggs with pecorino from Pienza. You can also get Montalto's own olive oil and wine. The brioche and bread are a must from the local baker.
I could go on, but I will end by saying that anyone who visits Castello di Montalto will experience something extremely special, and will make memories to last a lifetime.

5 Nov 2009 - review from tripadvisor.com

cj80128 (Denver, CO)

"Perfect Setting, Perfect Accommodations, Wonderful Hosts"
In the midst of a 17 day trip to Italy, we were lucky enough to find this Castello in the heart of Chianti - Wine country. Our hosts were so wonderful and the accommodations were perfect. Very American friendly. There were 8 of us traveling together and we had large spacious rooms each with it's own bathroom. The house we stayed in had a large open Kitchen, Living area and a large Loggia (deck). It was the perfect place to tour the Italian Tuscany area, close to Siena, Florence and the wine districts in Montalcino. We stayed for a full week and it was the best part of our trip!

21 Nov 2009 - review from tripadvisor.com

nins7 (London)

"Paradise"
We've been coming here for years and I think it must be one of the most beautiful places in the world. It's sheer Tuscan gorgeousness in a secluded castle surrounded by forests and amazing views of rolling hills. The hosts are incredibly thoughtful and friendly. The houses are very pretty but in a low-key, Italian style - don't expect five-star swankiness.

9 Oct 2009 - review from tripadvisor.com

HappyMango (Berthoud, Colorado)

Enchanting and Relaxing We stayed for a week at Montalto in the old school house, we loved it. The castle and grounds are absolutely amazing! Diana and Giovanni are wonderful and very willing to share their indepth knowledge of the castle and surrounding area. We loved having so much privacy, the nights were perfectly quiet. We were lucky enough to experience a few afternoon thunderstorms, which gave us a reason to make use of our fireplace. Our 'little house' was very comfortable, the bed and linens were quite nice. I've noticed that a few other reviews mention updating the accomodations and though that would be nice, it would also raise the rates - for the price our place was great. We didn't get to see the other accomodations, so we can't speak for them. There is a very nice swimming pool, a tennis court and even a bocce court. Montalto is a perfect location for exploring Siena, Florence, Assisi, Montalcino and more. We do plan to go back one day!

8 Oct 2009 - review from tripadvisor.com

merygreeke (London)

"Heavenly"
I first stayed at Montalto when I was seven. Since then I've gone back every year I can make it (I'm now 29).
There's a peace and a beauty at Montalto that you don't get anywhere else. The landscape is stunning and because you're miles away from anywhere you can see the stars and hear the forest at night. That's after you've gone for a cheeky midnight swim in the pool or stopped off to pick some herbs to cook with the vegetables that were grown by Giovanni and Diana's mates.
It's really not a hotel and people who come expecting standard hotel blandness will be disappointed. It's much more interesting and individual than that. All the cottages and outhouses have been done up separately, so you feel as though you're living in your own private 15th century house (although totally luxurious).
Parts of the main castle are about a thousand years old and once a week Giovanni and Diana, who are incredibly friendly, have a tea so you can go and have cake and lemonade with them, hear the castle's history and look at the 16th-century murals on the walls.
It's a short drive from Siena which is itself a completely addictive, beautiful and lovable town, and an equally short drive from Arezzo, the home of gorgeous buildings, antique shops and comedy jousting. In between are twenty tiny Tuscan villages which all have some amazing or bizarre thing to make them stand out.
Really, it makes you feel like you'd forgotten how it felt to be alive. I'd spend all year there if I could.

Oct 2009 - review from tripadvisor.com

ll127 (Miami, FL)

“A genuine Italian experience - cannot get better than this” The views are breathtaking, there is horseback riding and many wineries nearby. Spa mud treatments just down the road. My favorite Italian restaurant is just at the bottom of the mountain "Il Bivacco". Giovanni and Diana are the most attentive and wonderful hosts. Stay a week or a month, you will not regret it!

20 Feb 2009 - review from tripadvisor.com

tropeabeachdude (Toronto)

"Great Views but accomodations lacking"
The castle itself is beautiful as are the grounds and the hosts friendly and accomodating. The surrounding towns are amazing and you can explore them at your leisure. The experience is amazing. This property could be a 10 if only the accomodations were updated. Need new comfortable beds. Updated bathrooms and kitchens are necessary. Everything else is fantastic!

18 Aug 2009 - review from tripadvisor.com

kp1London (London)

"Perfect re-union"
We had a college re-union and a combined 50th birthday party at Montalto in the first week of August. There were 8 of us with families for a total of 23 people. We rented 6 apartments. It was the most perfect place I can imagine for such an affair. We felt that we had rented an entire village, it felt so cozy.
Montalto is very well located, several km from any town but still close enough for day trips to Siena, Florence and a number of other small towns in Tuscany. On the outside, it has the look you would imagine it must have had a 1000 years ago, but the apartments are all very comfortable and furnished with taste. There are so many original features in each of the apartments that the past never seems far away. The sky was amazingly clear, the air was perfect, the pool was refreshing.
The owners Giovanni and Diana were very helpful with information and directions and even gave us a tour of their house, which is also in the castle. If they were to sell it, we would queue up to buy it.
It is the perfect place for families and re-unions. There is even a lovely chapel in the castle, so it would also make a great place for a wedding with 40-50 guests.

9 Aug 2008 - review from tripadvisor.com

Isabelle Wolbert

Le charme et le calme de la campagne, l'élégance seigneuriale d'un château et de ses dépendances transformées en confortables appartements de vacances, en accueil amical et attentionné...tout cela près des sites touristiques de la Toscane et de l'Ombrie, à l'abri des collines du Chianti... Un rêve.

20 Nov 2008 - review from lapaquerette.com




back to homepage   |    site map   |    location   |    prices   |    availabilities   |    how to reserve   |    contact us